Doing everything right and the scale still won’t budge? If you have an underactive thyroid, that frustration is completely understandable.
Here’s the reassuring part: hypothyroidism can make weight loss harder, but it doesn’t make it impossible. Once your thyroid is properly treated, your body responds to diet and exercise the same way anyone else’s does.
In this article, we’re covering what hypothyroidism is, how it’s diagnosed and treated, how much weight it really accounts for, and the food, exercise and lifestyle habits that help.
Please work with your doctor. This article is general information, not a substitute for medical care. Don’t change or stop your thyroid medication, or start supplements, without talking to them first.
Hypothyroidism and weight at a glance
| Weight it usually causes | About 5 to 10 lb, mostly salt and water |
| After treatment | Losing weight works the same as for anyone else |
| Most important step | Getting diagnosed and treated, then taking your medication correctly |
| Best habits | Eating a little less, plenty of protein, strength training, good sleep |
| Avoid | Large amounts of seaweed or iodine supplements, and using thyroid pills to lose weight |
Save this guide to your Pinterest board for later
What is hypothyroidism?
Hypothyroidism, also called an underactive thyroid, is when your thyroid gland doesn’t make enough thyroid hormone. Your thyroid is a small, butterfly shaped gland at the front of your neck.
Thyroid hormones control how your body uses energy, so they affect nearly every organ in your body. When levels are low, a lot of things slow down.
It’s very common. About 20 million Americans have some form of thyroid disease, up to 60% of them don’t know it, and women are 5 to 8 times more likely than men to have thyroid problems.
Where people get enough iodine, like the US, the most common cause is Hashimoto’s disease, where your immune system attacks your thyroid.
Symptoms of hypothyroidism
Symptoms develop slowly and vary from person to person. The most common ones are:
- Tiredness
- Weight gain
- Feeling cold more easily
- Joint and muscle pain
- Dry skin, or dry and thinning hair
- Heavy or irregular periods, or fertility problems
- A slower heart rate
- Low mood or depression
Many of these, especially tiredness and weight gain, are common and don’t necessarily mean you have a thyroid problem. A blood test is the only way to know.
Why it matters to get it treated
Left untreated, hypothyroidism can contribute to high cholesterol, and it can affect your periods and fertility.
Very rarely, severe untreated hypothyroidism leads to myxedema coma, a life threatening slowdown of the body that needs emergency care.
The good news is that treatment is simple and effective for most people.
How hypothyroidism is diagnosed
Your doctor will usually check two things with a blood test:
- TSH, or thyroid stimulating hormone. It’s the signal your brain sends to tell your thyroid to work. If your thyroid is underactive, your TSH goes up.
- Free T4, the thyroid hormone your body can actually use.
What about the “gray zone”?
Sometimes TSH is a little high but free T4 is still normal. This is called subclinical, or mild, hypothyroidism.
Whether to treat it is a real debate. A 2019 guideline panel recommended against thyroid medication for most adults with mild hypothyroidism, because it didn’t improve how people felt. That advice doesn’t apply if you’re trying to get pregnant, your TSH is above 20, or you’re young or have severe symptoms.
In a large trial of older adults with mild hypothyroidism, a year of medication made no difference to symptoms or tiredness compared with a placebo.
So if your results are borderline, ask your doctor about retesting in a few months rather than assuming one result tells the whole story.
Thyroid medication: what to know
The standard treatment is levothyroxine, a daily pill that replaces the hormone your thyroid isn’t making. Brand names include Synthroid, Levoxyl and Unithroid. Major guidelines say it should remain the standard of care.
It controls hypothyroidism but doesn’t cure it, so most people take it for life. And it can take several weeks to notice a difference.
How to take it so it works
How you take it matters, because food and some supplements block absorption:
- Take it on an empty stomach, 30 minutes to 1 hour before breakfast
- Keep calcium and iron supplements at least 4 hours away from it
- Soy, walnuts and high fiber foods can affect it, so keep your eating consistent and tell your doctor about big diet changes
- Above all, be consistent: take it the same way every day
What about side effects?
When your dose is right, most people feel better, not worse. Symptoms like a racing heart, trouble sleeping or feeling anxious can be a sign of too much thyroid hormone, so tell your doctor. They can adjust your dose with a simple blood test.
How to lose weight with hypothyroidism
Here’s what the American Thyroid Association says, and it’s genuinely encouraging.
For most people, hypothyroidism accounts for about 5 to 10 lb of weight gain, and most of that is salt and water rather than fat. Treatment usually brings that back off.
Once your thyroid levels are back in the normal range, your ability to lose weight is the same as anyone else’s.
What does that mean for you? If you’re treated and still struggling, your thyroid is probably no longer the main thing standing in your way. The same things that work for everyone will work for you too:
- Get your levels right first. Work with your doctor until your TSH is in range.
- Eat a little less than you burn. A small, steady calorie deficit is easier to stick with. Our tips on how to eat less without feeling deprived can help.
- Prioritize protein at every meal. Higher protein diets may help with appetite and keeping muscle while you lose weight.
- Lift weights two or three times a week to hold on to muscle while you lose fat.
- Move more every day, with walks and some cardio you enjoy.
- Sleep and manage stress, because both affect your appetite and energy.
And one thing to avoid: taking extra thyroid hormone to lose weight. It raises the risk of heart rhythm problems, bone loss and anxiety, and the weight usually comes back when you stop.
From our shopOur 30 High Protein Recipes cookbook has breakfasts, lunches, dinners and snacks, with the calories, protein, carbs and fat on every recipe.
What to eat with hypothyroidism
There’s no special thyroid diet. Eat the way that’s good for your whole body, with mostly whole, filling foods:
- Protein: chicken, fish, eggs, Greek yogurt, beans and lentils
- Fiber: vegetables, fruit, beans and whole grains
- Healthy fats: salmon, olive oil, nuts and seeds
- Selenium rich foods: Brazil nuts, tuna, sardines and eggs
- Zinc rich foods: beef, shellfish, pumpkin seeds and yogurt
Research on specific diets for Hashimoto’s is still early, and a 2023 review found it’s still unclear which dietary approach helps most.
Be careful with iodine
Your thyroid needs iodine to make its hormones, and most people get enough from iodized salt, dairy, eggs and seafood.
But if you have Hashimoto’s, large amounts of iodine from kelp, seaweed or supplements may cause or worsen hypothyroidism. So skip iodine supplements and seaweed supplements unless your doctor recommends them. That includes many “thyroid support” products, which often contain iodine.
Cut back on added sugar
Added sugar adds calories without filling you up, which makes a calorie deficit harder. Check labels on cereals, flavored yogurts and sauces, where it often hides.
What about gluten?
If you have celiac disease or a gluten intolerance, a gluten free diet is essential. If you don’t, cutting gluten is one of the diets people try for Hashimoto’s, but the research is small and early, and it’s still unclear which approach helps most. If you’re thinking of going gluten free, ask your doctor about a celiac test first.
Do goitrogens matter?
Foods like broccoli, cabbage, cauliflower and soy contain goitrogens, substances that can interfere with how your thyroid uses iodine. They’re also very healthy foods, so there’s no need to cut them out. Eating them cooked and as part of a varied diet is the simple middle ground, and your doctor can advise if you eat a lot of soy.
Should you take supplements for your thyroid?
Most people don’t need special thyroid supplements, and some popular ones can do harm.
Selenium is the one with the most research. A 2024 review of 35 studies found selenium lowered thyroid antibodies in people with Hashimoto’s. But an earlier Cochrane review judged the evidence on how people actually feel too unreliable to guide decisions. If you’re curious, ask your doctor, because too much selenium can be harmful too.
Iodine and “thyroid boosting” blends: best avoided unless your doctor prescribes them, for the reasons above.
Vitamins and minerals: if you’re low in something like vitamin D, B12 or iron, a blood test can show it, and your doctor can tell you what to take.
Exercise with hypothyroidism
When you’re tired all the time, exercise can feel like the last thing you want to do. Start small.
- Strength training two or three times a week helps you keep muscle, which matters even more as you get older. Try our women’s full body gym workout.
- Walking or easy cardio most days helps your energy and mood. Our guide to the best cardio for weight loss can help you choose.
- Build up slowly. If your levels have only just been corrected, give yourself a few weeks to get your energy back.
Manage stress and sleep
Stress and poor sleep both make it harder to stick to healthy habits, and they can leave you feeling even more tired.
A few things that help:
- Keep a regular bedtime and wake time
- Try yoga, a walk outdoors or a few minutes of slow breathing each day
- Journal or talk to someone you trust
Takeaways
- Hypothyroidism is common, especially in women, and very treatable.
- Most thyroid related weight gain is 5 to 10 lb and mostly water.
- Once your levels are right, you can lose weight the same way as anyone else.
- Take your medication on an empty stomach, consistently, away from calcium and iron.
- Be careful with iodine and “thyroid boosting” supplements, especially with Hashimoto’s.
- Focus on a small calorie deficit, protein, strength training, sleep and stress.
You’ve got this. Be patient with your body, and keep working with your doctor.
This article is for general information and is not medical advice. Always talk to your doctor before changing your medication, diet or supplements, especially if you’re pregnant, planning a pregnancy or have other health conditions.